A tie?? What the heck?
November 18th, 2008
In Week 11 of the NFL, the Bengals and the Eagles tied, 13-13. That’s right, they tied. The National Football League, maybe the greatest sporting business in the world, allowed a game to finish with no winner. Why? Simple, television. Games can’t be going long because they will run into the other games scheduled after them! Stupid.
The media is all over Eagles quarterback Donovan McNabb for his post-game comments regarding the tie. McNabb said he didn’t realize the game would end after one OT. Then he questioned what would happen in a playoff game or the Super Bowl. OK, the second statement was pretty unintelligent, but who cares about that? This is football, not Mensa.
It is ridiculous the criticism McNabb is receiving for not know about the tie rule in football. Do you think ANY player in ANY profession league or association knows even close to all the rules? No, because if they did, you wouldn’t need refs. For someone like Tiki Barber to call McNabb’s lack of knowledge “indefensible” is moronic. Barber says that McNabb should have had more urgency in the final drive…well, if he wasn’t being urgent enough, where was Head Coach Andy Reid to hurry him along and say “Hey, we need to score or it’s a tie”?
Tiki, since you never played QB, and never had the responsibility of directing a game-winning drive EVER, I’m sure you know how easy it is to remember an obscure rule in OT after taking hits all game.
The last tie game was in 2002. There have only been 17 in 34 years. No exactly a rule that is in everyone’s face. I’ll bet if you put most players and many sports writers on the spot, they would struggle to remember what the rule is.
Regardless of all of that, the really problem is the rule itself. It is stupid. Ridiculous. Out-dated. Stubborn. There isn’t a single other professional OR college or high school major sport that allows for a tie. NOT ONE. Even hockey did away with ties a few years ago, although their records and standings are slightly different regarding OT. Basketball? No way. Texas A&M and Baylor went into 5OT last year in College Station. Baseball. Maybe, but those would be on account of weather or other outlandish circumstances, and the MLB allows for make-up games, plus they play 162, so one tie doesn’t hurt much. Oh, wait, there is soccer. The MLS allows for ties. Congrats, NFL, you can be directly linked to the MLS.
Roger Goodell, or whomever can make this call, change the rule! Come on! This is stupid! I know you won’t go to the NCAA system because you don’t want to be a follower and all, but ties are ridiculous. What happens if, lets say, the Eagles finish at 10-5-1 and the Cowboys finish at 10-6, both tied for the wildcard spot. Who gets it?
I don’t know the rule, but I bet it would go to the Cowboys. Initially, you would think, thats right, because the Eagles tied and could have lost. But then, that means you are basically counting a tie as a loss, so why have ties? If thats the case, then 2 out of 3 results in any NFL game result in a “loss.” Again, ridiculous. But you couldn’t give the nod to the Eagles, because then you are saying that a tie really is a win. For a third time, ridiculous.
NFL, get your act together. Don’t blame players for not knowing stupid rules that never apply in ANY OTHER SPORT they have ever played. Get this fixed. You are an embarrassment.
TO is still incredible, even if he pops his mouth off or cries; Romo is averaging over 250 yards a game, and Wade has the Cowboys at 4-1. Good stuff.
Baylor Bears

Kansas Jayhawks
modest salary, penning words of wisdom for the masses, did to you that you feel vindicated in torturing me so in your Week 1 performance? What was it, my broken-nosed God of the pigskin, that caused you to take a metaphorical dump on the field on Sunday, throwing for less than 100 yards and racking up a dismal 4.5 points for me, damning my team to almost certain death and Week 1 floggery?