This one has been on my mind for a while…
This past summer, one of my best friends had her first baby. During her pregnancy, she discussed and planned how she would like to pursue a non-medicated, natural childbirth-even hiring a Doula to help her through the birthing process. I was surprised by her adamancy on the topic, and worried she would be disappointed should something not go according to her “birth plan.” In my own experience with childbirth, I didn’t have an actual plan for birthing other than getting the baby OUT, but then I failed to progress at all, which resulted in a c-section (times three). Per my doctor’s orders, once a section, always a section-especially with births less than three years apart. Also, in her experience, failure to progress was a repetitive problem. So, labor and delivery of babies was not something I excelled at, but as my friend put it, I still won at the carnival, and got to go home with a baby (three times!). As I went through the experience, I didn’t feel deprived of anything necessary to my life as a mother-until I got home and started reading all those parenting magazines. There, spelled out for me was every sad and lonely feeling I should be having for being limited in my “birth experience,” not only the birth of my child, but the “birth of my motherhood.” It was then that I began freaking out, wondering why those feelings weren’t welling up inside of me, and if perhaps I should have “tried harder” for a “real birth.” I quickly got over that freak-out moment, but there was always this nagging voice in the back of my head reminding me of that “lost experience.”
Going through the experience with my friend this summer brought all those inadequate feelings back to the surface. Without intention, she seemed to downplay the way my babies entered the world. She was well read in all things labor and delivery, and had vast information on labor positions, breathing techniques, side effects of pain medication, and statistics on c-sections. I read up a little more on the topic, just to be informed and subsequently questioned every decision I had made with my pregnancies. I felt lost in the medical system, and disappointed with my results.
And then I slapped myself.
Because, I DID win at the carnival. No matter what struggles my body did or did not experience, I DID take my babies home. I’m STILL a mom, and I STILL am figuring out all the things that go along with that amazing responsibility and blessing.
But, during my reading and research this summer, I found a wealth of negative reporting on c-sections, medicated births, and more positive information on non-medicated natural births. Women who “ended up” with sections were adamant on VBACS for their second child, so their “birthing experience” would be complete. It could have been the sources, and the types of people on both sides of that issue telling their stories in different ways, but I was a little surprised. I began to wonder that with everything women and moms in general have on their plates, why we need lay on the guilt for HOW the babies are born? Really?
And I’m a fan of incense and crystals. My friends would tell you that I would be the first to go with the filling the room with positive energy and an aura of light and happiness. I’d like to do that right now, on my couch. I love the women that are capable of having that birth experience; I’m so happy for them. I just think it’s kind of a non-issue how the babies arrive. Sure, make a birth plan-any birth plan, and then everyone celebrate the bundle of joy-and not diminish however that experience happened.
And despite my friend’s best laid plans, she delivered via c-section, too. I was immediately concerned for her disappointment, but the happy tears in her eyes told me she didn’t care. She’d won at the carnival too. Sometimes, it seems, it’s the babies that do all the deciding.
Now, let’s go get some funnel cake.
You’re right, you DID win at the carnival. It does not matter how the babies got here, the blessing is that they are here. A few short hours of the labor of “the birth of your motherhood” is nothing compared to the lifetime motherhood experience those kiddos will bring you.
And you know what? You got to experience the carnival rides of pregnancy. There are tons of fabulous mothers out there that didn’t get to go on those rides and through adoption still got to bring home the prize.
Also, let’s not forget all those mothers who play the carnival games time and time again, and still don’t have the prize to take home.
So in the big picture of things, you are one of the luckiest mome out there.
I delivered via C-section and have two adopted children…. I am so glad to hear your words on this. Others have questioned the role of a mother without a natural delivery. I think that the “getting” is the easy part no matter how you get there, it’s the “keeping” that makes you a mom!
Great job!
I’m going to have to agree, even though i dont have kids. the bundles of joy you produced are irreplaceable!
You know I agree with you 10000000% and I have to add into the mix the issue of breast feeding vs. bottle. Another source of guilt thrown into that crazy newborn time! So I may not have been the prehistoric woman that survived childbirth AND could feed her children well too….but afterall this is not prehistoric times and formula has all of that good breastmilk protein in it now anyways! RELEASE the guilt….all of us! Lift each other up….!
I think the real question in all of this isn’t how someone chooses to birth or even whether or not that mom’s choice is what the baby has in mind but whether or not we have any choices at all in birthing. It wasn’t too long ago that all women were put under to deliver and the men were kept in the wiating room…things do change. The “once a section always a section” delivery method is now being questioned by medical literature and yet many hospitals in the Metroplex will not allow a VBAC or even a trial of labor after an initial cesarean delivery.
Clearly all mothers and mothers-to-be have the same goal in mind, a healthy baby, but when there is little choice given to the mother in how that baby arrives it can cause an otherwise joyous time to be fraught with stress. Because healthcare issues are in the national spotlight right now this is a very timely issue but I’d suggest that it is always an important issue for women to be aware of. Not because of any perceived guilt-factor or one-upsmanship in the mommy wars but because when our medical choices are limited we all lose. Cesarean deliveries are expensive, as my pocketbook can attest, and that does have an effect on everyone’s insurance premiums. Uncomplicated vaginal deliveries are the far cheapest option in birthing and if a mother chooses to attempt a VBAC, barring any medical emergency, she should be allowed to.
All that aside, as a new mother I can definitely see how each parenting choice puts you on one side or the other of some debate, I suppose it’s all we can do to just keep up with what side we’re on. And of course, share the funnel cake.
great comments ladies! It almost feels like a little chat over coffee.
Actually, ACOG no longer makes a blanket policy statement against VBAC although they do advise of the risks you mention, specifically uterine rupture. ACOG also advises of the risks of repeat c-sections. Clearly, birth, no matter what the course, is risky. It wasn’t my intention to indicate that VBAC was somehow preferred but that it’s an option for subsequent births. Unfortunately, it is an option only for some women. It should be an option to any woman who wants to pursue that course of delivery but partially because of the insurance premiums you mentioned many hospitals and OBs are not willing to allow a woman to pursue a VBAC whether or not she is a good candidate or not.
Where’s my post?